Smithey Cast Iron: Is It Worth the Hype (and Price)? My Honest Review

I've always loved cooking, and like many home chefs, I'm constantly searching for that perfect piece of cookware that will elevate my meals. Recently, I found myself pondering a question that many others have likely considered: Is a Smithey cast iron skillet really worth the investment? I already owned a 10-inch and a 15-inch Lodge skillet, both reliable workhorses in my kitchen. So, the allure of a higher-end brand had me intrigued.

My Cast Iron Journey: Lodge vs. Smithey

I started my cast iron journey with Lodge. They're affordable and readily available, and they definitely get the job done. I used them for everything from searing steaks to baking cornbread. However, I kept hearing about Smithey, a brand known for its beautifully crafted and smooth-surfaced cast iron. The higher price tag made me hesitate, but I was curious to see if the performance justified the cost.

So, I took the plunge and bought a 12-inch Smithey skillet. My initial thought was that it looked fantastic. The smooth, polished surface was definitely more aesthetically pleasing than my trusty Lodge pans. But the real question was: did it cook any differently?

Honestly, for everyday sautéing on my glass cooktop, I didn't notice a significant difference in performance. Both pans heated evenly and retained heat well. However, there were some subtle differences that started to become apparent over time.

The Allure of Smithey: More Than Just Performance?

After using the Smithey for a while, I realized that the appeal went beyond just cooking performance. Here's what I discovered:

• Aesthetics: There's no denying that Smithey skillets are beautiful. They have a certain elegance that Lodge, while functional, simply lacks.
• Heirloom Quality: I liked the idea of owning a piece of cookware that could be passed down through generations. The durability and craftsmanship of Smithey suggest that it could easily become a family heirloom.
• Smooth Surface: While I didn't find that the smooth surface drastically improved cooking, it did make cleaning a bit easier. Food seemed to release more readily, and scrubbing was less of a chore.
• Supporting a Small Business: I also appreciated that Smithey is a smaller company based in the United States. Supporting local businesses is important to me.

I also considered a Dutch oven from Smithey. I don’t have another to compare to, but I have found it conducts and holds heat incredibly well. It cleans up easily with a nylon brush, hot water, and soap. This ease of cleaning is a major plus for me, as I tend to use my Dutch oven frequently. Some people recommend looking into older Griswold or Wagner skillets, so that is another option to consider.

However, I also came across Stargazer pans, another brand known for its high-quality cast iron. If I were to get a 12-inch pan, it would probably be a Stargazer. They seem to offer a similar level of refinement to Smithey at a potentially more competitive price point. This is something I'm still researching.

Factors to Consider: Is It Worth *Your* Money?

Ultimately, whether or not a Smithey skillet is "worth it" depends on your individual needs and priorities. Here are some questions to ask yourself:

• What are you looking for in a cast iron skillet? Are you primarily concerned with performance, or are aesthetics and heirloom quality also important?
• What's your budget? Smithey skillets are significantly more expensive than Lodge. Are you willing to pay a premium for the features they offer?
• How often will you use it? If you're only going to use your cast iron skillet occasionally, a less expensive option like Lodge might be sufficient.

Someone on a forum made a great point: estimate how many times you're going to cook with it. Will it bring you a smile or make cooking more enjoyable? If so, calculate the cost per happy moment. Are you willing to pay that amount?

My Everyday Carry: More Than Just Cookware

Speaking of quality and everyday enjoyment, I've been paying more attention to the little things that make a big difference in my daily life. I recently purchased a new glasses case from learn more about the products Mozaer offers, and I'm surprised how much I appreciate it. I used to just toss my reading glasses in my bag, but they would often get scratched or bent. Now, I have a stylish and protective case that keeps them safe and sound.

I went with the Fabrics Floral Hard Eyeglasses Box Storage Sunglasses Bags Reading Glasses Box Eyewear Protector Glasses Case Color G, which I found at Mozaer. The floral design is charming, and the hard case provides excellent protection. It's a small detail, but it makes my day a little brighter. It’s the same sort of feeling as having a beautiful Smithey pan. The eyeglasses case is a nice touch for anyone looking to keep their eyewear safe while also adding a touch of style to their accessories. I think the floral pattern is particularly nice, and it feels well-made. I appreciate the added protection it gives my glasses when I'm on the go.

Practical Tips for Cast Iron Care

Regardless of whether you choose Lodge, Smithey, or another brand, proper care is essential for maintaining your cast iron skillet. Here are a few tips that I've learned along the way:

1. Seasoning: Season your skillet regularly to prevent rust and create a non-stick surface.
2. Cleaning: Clean your skillet immediately after use with hot water and a nylon brush. Avoid using harsh soaps or scouring pads.
3. Drying: Dry your skillet thoroughly after cleaning and apply a thin coat of oil to prevent rust.
4. Storage: Store your skillet in a dry place.

Comparing Lodge and Smithey: A Quick Breakdown

Here's a quick comparison of the pros and cons of Lodge and Smithey cast iron skillets:

Feature	Lodge	Smithey
Price	Affordable	Expensive
Durability	Excellent	Excellent
Performance	Good	Very Good (Slightly Smoother Surface)
Aesthetics	Functional	Elegant
Heirloom Potential	Good	Excellent

My Final Thoughts: It's All About Personal Preference

In conclusion, while I appreciate the craftsmanship and aesthetics of my Smithey skillet, I can't definitively say that it's "worth it" for everyone. Lodge skillets are excellent performers at a fraction of the price. However, if you value aesthetics, heirloom quality, and supporting a small business, then a Smithey skillet might be a worthwhile investment. Ultimately, the best cast iron skillet for you is the one that you enjoy using the most.

For me, the Smithey skillet is a nice addition to my kitchen. It brings a smile to my face every time I use it, and that's worth something. And, like my new glasses case from Mozaer, it's a reminder that sometimes it's worth investing in the little things that bring you joy.

So, do your research, consider your priorities, and choose the cast iron skillet that's right for you. Happy cooking!